Enquire about consultancy
Book a free one-to-one consultation to review the current state of your digital workplace and discover how DWG expert guidance can help you move forward with confidence.
In this episode of Digital Workplace Impact, Nancy Goebel is joined by Stan Garfield, a highly respected knowledge management (KM) author, speaker, community leader and practitioner with more than three decades of experience in the field. Together, they explore what those years of KM practice can teach us about making AI genuinely useful – and how to avoid some familiar mistakes.
Human–AI teaming and governance: Patterns, practices and guardrails for the AI-enabled workplace
As generative AI reshapes the digital workplace, are organizations in danger of rushing headlong towards the new while neglecting what we already know works?
In this episode of Digital Workplace Impact, Nancy Goebel is joined by Stan Garfield, a highly respected knowledge management (KM) author, speaker, community leader and practitioner with more than three decades of experience in the field. Together, they explore what those years of KM practice can teach us about making AI genuinely useful – and how to avoid some familiar mistakes.
Stan argues that AI shouldn’t be used to paper over weak processes or replace the human connections that make knowledge flow. Instead, organizations need to get the fundamentals right first – from effective communities and repositories to well-designed processes – and then consider how AI can make them even better.
The conversation explores AI as an augmentation of human intelligence, its untapped potential beyond ‘glorified search’, and the enduring importance of communities in connecting people and knowledge. Stan also shares his perspective on community participation, challenges some accepted assumptions about engagement, and makes the case for using evidence to understand what really creates value.
For digital workplace and KM leaders navigating the AI era, this thoughtful conversation brings decades of experience to one of today’s biggest questions: how can we embrace what’s new without losing sight of what we already know works?
Episode 176: What AI can learn from 30 years of knowledge management
You want to get your processes working well before you try to use AI to improve them. If you try to throw AI at a process that’s not working well, it’ll just not work very well with AI.
Stan Garfield
Knowledge Management Author, Speaker and Community Leader
Nancy Goebel
The question on my mind today is what can three decades of knowledge management teach us about getting AI right? In this episode of Digital Workplace Impact, I’m joined by Stan Garfield, author, speaker and community leader. And together we explore why the fundamentals of knowledge sharing still matter, what successful organizations consistently get right, and how leaders can build stronger foundations for AI.
This is Nancy Goebel, DWG’s Chief Executive and your host. Digital Workplace Impact is brought to you by Digital Workplace Group. Join me now in conversation with Stan. Happy listening!
Nancy
Stan, I’m delighted to welcome you to the Digital Workplace Impact podcast studio. Thank you for stepping out of a busy day to come into conversation with us.
Stan Garfield
Well, I’m glad to be here.
Nancy
I just want to kick things off by saying it’s been really interesting to see how generative AI has launched a whole new focus around knowledge management. And you’re someone who has operated in the KM space for, gosh, three decades or more, and I’m really curious to hear what’s surprised you most about this moment, this convergence of KM with artificial intelligence, and anything that you can share about what successful organizations are doing right in this moment in time.
Stan
Well it’s interesting that AI has come back. It’s been around for a long time! Many people think it’s brand new, but it’s been around longer than we’ve had the field of knowledge management with that name. But it’s gotten a lot of emphasis because of the large language models that are in wide use now. And, not unlike other brief fads that have come around in knowledge management over the last 30 years, it’s become the main focal point of most of the promotional materials I receive now. So, if I get a mail message promoting something related to knowledge management, it almost inevitably will include AI in it. So, it’s the sort of the hot thing of the moment. But I think unlike some of the past hot things of the moment, this one is going to be with us – and so the challenge for us is to figure out how to use it effectively. And right now I think we’re not necessarily doing a real good job with that. Everybody’s dazzled by it and it’s ubiquitous
Nancy
(Laughs)
Stan
But they’re not all putting it to the greatest use. One of the interesting things I notice when I see commercials on TV for AI – which you’re seeing more of nowadays, so you’ll see Gemini and you’ll see ChatGPT advertising on TV – but even back when Alexa was first introduced, these ads don’t really have very compelling use cases. They try to impress something on the audience, but I think this is the challenge for AI in general. We haven’t really come up with the best use cases for it yet. It has tremendous capability and potential, but we haven’t really tapped it very well. So, for example, in knowledge management, many, many KM organizations are using it more like an extension of search.
Nancy
Yes.
Stan
So, it’s a search with more capability, easier to interact with, can do more, but there’s so much more that it could do beyond being an extension of search. It could really help us with doing many of the tasks that we’ve been doing less effectively over the years.
Let’s take one example. You know, when we’ve tried to add metadata to content, that’s always been a challenge. People don’t want to add metadata to content, or they don’t do it very well, or it’s just left out altogether. And AI can help with that. It can do automatic classification and it could do probably a better job than just leaving it up to contributors – but it won’t necessarily do a better job than an expert knowledge manager might do, who would look at it and have greater context around it.
So I think that’s the challenge. It’s harnessing AI to help us do things, but giving it the right context and doing it in conjunction with humans in many cases, augmenting our human capabilities, not necessarily replacing them. We talk about it in terms of automating processes. Once again, I don’t think we’ve done a great job with that just yet. But to the greatest extent possible, if we can figure out processes that we can have AI help us do more effectively and allow the humans to do things that we do most effectively, and view it in that role as augmenting human intelligence, then I think there’s great potential. But I think we’re just sort of scratching the surface so far when it comes to that.
Nancy
And I think one of the dangers we have right now is that knowledge management could end up being treated as a technology challenge when it’s so much more than that. You’ve long emphasized the importance of people and communities in the knowledge management arena. Let’s talk a little bit about that and why. You’ve seen the importance of that in looking at successful organizations.
Stan
A couple of things that come to mind: one is that knowledge is actually in our brains and it’s socially constructed. It’s not written down. We often get confused with that. But technology can be really good for helping us manage information. But knowledge usually is something that humans possess. So the fact that technology can’t do that but can help support it. That’s an important concept.
You asked me about what’s surprising. One of the things that surprises me is that after 30 years of doing knowledge management, in some ways we’re still struggling with some of the same things we always have. So in communities, for example, we’ve known about communities longer than we’ve had knowledge management. They go back before that. And there have been effective online communities for 40 or more years. But there are still organizations out there that don’t understand that that’s one of the key things we can do in knowledge management. And so they get dazzled by technology and they neglect things like communities, which are relatively simple, but perhaps the most powerful. So where technology can blind us is that we’re looking for some AI tool rather than realizing that if we just did a better job of connecting the people in our organization so that they can interact, ask questions of each other, share information and so forth, that’ll actually deliver more value than some piece of technology.
So it’s not necessarily exciting to people to say they should focus on communities because it doesn’t necessarily involve anything that’s new or hot, but to me that’s still the greatest opportunity. And the fact that we’re not doing a better job of it, it would seem like by now every organization ought to be good at doing communities. We know how to do them; we’ve been doing them for many years. The organizations that do them well really get a lot of benefit out of it. But yet in the people that I interact with, some of the people that I serve as a mentor to, I’ll find out that they’re still struggling with this. So that’s surprising to me. It would be really nice if we all had communities working really well and then we took the next step, maybe for instance, using AI to help us in the facilitation and monitoring of communities or in the tagging of community discussions, but instead we’re not even doing the basics right in many cases, and that’s perhaps something that’s frustrating to me.
Nancy
Hmm. And if you had a chance to verbalize a recipe for success in the now with so many organizations trying to drive enterprise generative AI, what would be some of the core things in that recipe?
Stan
Well first I would say it’s to do the things that we’ve already known how to do and do them well before getting distracted, let’s say, by AI. So, if they haven’t been doing communities well and they haven’t done some of the basics with repositories and other KM technologies, get those right first. You want to get your processes working well before you try to use AI to improve them. If you try to throw AI at a process that’s not working well, it’ll just not work very well with AI. So, get your important processes working well first. If you don’t have communities working well, get them working well. Then you can use AI to make them even better. So that’s number one I would start with.
The second thing would be that I found that if you invest the time to really get to understand how to use tools like ChatGPT and like Claude and like Gemini and Copilot, if you’re able to use those to do more than just glorified search – it takes a little bit of time. You have to invest time, you have to interact with one of those tools like it’s a colleague, and you go back and forth. Let’s say you’re trying to work on some kind of onboarding procedure using AI to help do it. You might want to try to train your AI tool to deliver that in the way that you would deliver it. You’re going to have to spend time with that tool going back and forth and looking at different iterations of it and saying, ‘No, not that, more like this’. And the people that invest the time and do that well will get the most out of AI and they can produce really impressive results. But if you don’t invest that time, if you just want to ask it a question and have it come back, you’ll never get to the point where you can have it really do the things that it could do.
So, I think that’s the two things. It’s number one, get your current processes working well before you try to use AI. And number two, invest the time to really learn how to use AI to its fullest potential, not just in its simplest form.
Nancy
Sage advice, of course. And it certainly makes me wonder if over the generations of knowledge management that you’ve seen and shaped and influenced, what’s different about knowledge management now compared to some of those prior generations?
Stan
What’s different now is that we have more technology at our disposal to use. What’s not different is that in many cases we’re not any better off than we were, right? So the potential is there. Each time something new has come along over the last 30 years, there’s been the opportunity to use it, but we don’t always fully exploit it.
Let’s look at one example. Somewhere around 2000 or so, we had something we called Web 2.0 at the time. We don’t really even call it that anymore but it was the use of some new collaborative technologies that came into vogue. It included blogs and wikis and RSS feeds and podcasts and videos and so forth. Once again there was great excitement back then for that. But did we all use those to the fullest potential? I don’t think so.
Take an example: wikis. Wiki always represented an opportunity to collaboratively edit, right? To let multiple people share in doing the editing of any particular document. And that felt like a good thing. And we had an example of the Wikipedia encyclopedia that worked really well. But we haven’t had any great success in really using wikis inside of enterprises. So, it’s an example of where there was potential and there was excitement amongst a few KM people, but it never really caught on, probably because people didn’t really want to edit wikis, and wikis tended then just to be edited by the creator rather than by the multitudes.
And I think the same thing could happen with any technology, that there’s excitement for it, but then if you don’t fully implement it well then the excitement can wane. So I could see definitely you talk about the curve of disillusionment with the hype cycle, where people are probably already getting somewhat weary of hearing about AI because each time they hear about it, it sounds the same, right? So every day I receive probably two or three messages touting agentic AI and so forth. And how many of them are going to contain anything truly valuable? Not that many. They’re just sort of writing the slogans that come along. So, what we would have to do, I think, is to say ‘No, we’re not going to let it just be slogan-driven, or be this kind of surface level’, we’re going to have to do more with it. But each time a new technology comes along, there’s the opportunity for it to be embraced, but it can sometimes wane.
Another example would be enterprise social networks, which were an exciting development at one time – and I was one of the people that helped roll out Yammer when I was at Deloitte – and now Yammer is called Microsoft Viva Engage, but once again, that hasn’t caught on widely. All the organizations that have Microsoft 365 are not using Microsoft Viva Engage effectively, or at all. So the technology can be there, but we don’t always figure out how to make it omnipresent, so that it’s a given that everybody has it and uses it and uses it well.
Nancy
Hmm. And it a challenging time for us right now because there are some organizations that are viewing AI enablement in the enterprises synonymous with headcount and cost-cutting activities. And so, with your knowledge management domain expertise, what kinds of outcomes do you think organizations should be challenging themselves to think about in a wider conversation than just the headcount or cost paradigm?
Stan
Yes, there’s a real risk there that by thinking of it that way, we’ll end up in a real negative place because replacing human judgement with AI isn’t going to work, right? It can do a lot of things, but it can’t replace human judgement. So, if we’re smart about what we replace – for instance, let’s say you have an organization that has lots of people doing content cleansing or some kind of rote task, then that’s a good opportunity for AI perhaps to do that work. But if we instead say we’re going to just arbitrarily say we’ll replace n percent of our workforce with AI, that’s a bad idea.
So let’s figure out where it makes sense, where it can do certain processes. Once again, I’ll repeat, you have to get your processes working really well before you do that. But assuming that you do, there’ll be some opportunity for that. And then you should ask, what can we do instead? If we were spending a lot of time doing tasks that AI can also do, what could we do with that time? Not to eliminate, but to improve. So could we have people spending more time doing things that humans do well – engaging in conversation, facilitating communities, having actual human-to-human interaction that we perhaps in the past said we’re too busy doing rote tasks to do that.
I’ll give you an example of that: a community that I lead, which is called the SIKM Leaders Community. It’s a knowledge management community that’s been in existence for 21 years, so anyone who’s interested in knowledge management can belong to that community. Now, we have monthly calls where speakers come on and talk about important topics of knowledge management. Yet we only generally have around 20 people who ever attend the calls live. So think about that. We have over 1300 members, all of whom are supposedly knowledge management practitioners. Why are only 20 of them making the time to spend one hour a month to actually engage with a knowledgeable speaker? They’re probably doing something that’s not all that important. But to them, you know, ‘I’ve got to get this done’. And that’s a good example. If they instead spend the hour listening to that speaker, talking to that speaker, interacting with the other members on that call, that’s probably a better use of their time than whatever else they were going to do. So, if AI could do that other thing they were going to do, so they could spend the hour on the call, that would be a good outcome. That would be an example. We have to put more emphasis on what we humans do well and how AI can assist us and not on what AI can replace us with.
Nancy
Yes, we share a similar experience in the community arena and to hear you say that is very reassuring from a DWG standpoint because, you know, I hear countless times where leaders and their teams are double and triple booked in meetings and don’t even have time to process what it is that they’re taking in from one meeting to the next. And sometimes you need to step off the hamster-wheel to be able to take in fresh ideas or new approaches to things. And instead of thinking of it as one more thing to add to your ‘to-do’ list, actually that headspace can give you the moment that you need to come up with the solutions to the things that are keeping you up late at night outside of that meeting circuit. So, we’re very much kindred spirits in thinking about that. I also wonder, because there are some organizations that have had a tricky history with knowledge management, especially organizations I’d say that tried to tackle it in earnest in the 1990s. What would be your advice to them when sometimes leadership shudders at the thought of knowledge management coming back into the fold?
Stan
Certainly, many KM programmes have come and gone over the last 30 years. And it’s always been a sad realization that some of the very best ones that had nothing but success nonetheless were victims of being cut. What ends up happening typically is that after that happens, they have to resurrect them later. The need for knowledge management has never gone away. If anything, it’s only increased. But organizations who are faced with cost cutting or the impact of mergers or acquisitions, usually the KM represents a convenient target because it’s not a given in any organization that it will exist. So, the KM programme is not like Finance or Personnel or Legal or any given. No one’s going to come along and say we have to get rid of the Finance department. But they will go after KM. And so what can you do about that? Well as I say, it’s going to come back. In some cases it’s come back many times.
Nancy
Mm-hmm.
Stan
Because the need doesn’t go away. Now AI represents an opportunity. If the companies now think that AI is a given, which many of them probably do, where they didn’t think of KM that way, then if AI can be the way that KM becomes more permanent, then that’s a good thing. So, let’s say for example that there’s no Chief Knowledge Officer but there’s a Chief AI Officer, then maybe that’s the way. Let’s get in on that, let’s make KM a part of or a partner of AI. So now, if it’s more institutionalized in organizations, we can have some greater consistency. There’s always a risk down the road that AI might fall out of favour, but I think that’s less likely than KM. So, given that, use that as an opportunity. And I’ve advised people, you know, if there’s an AI department that seems to be getting a lot of funding and attention, then make sure you’re a good partner with them, if not actually integrated with them. That can be the avenue. So you do need the fundamentals of KM to do good AI. You’ve got to have good knowledge graphs, good knowledge bases and good content. And to me, it’s a very logical combination and that could be a way for KM programmes that have come and gone to maybe become more constant. But ultimately, as I say, any organization will realize at some point that it has to do a better job of reusing what it knows. So, whether you call that AI or whether you call that KM, I feel like it’s always going to be needed. And so therefore you’ll have the opportunity to do it, but maybe you can find a home for it that’s more stable.
Nancy
And whether embedded in an AI initiative or standing on its own, if a leader were charged with driving knowledge management from scratch tomorrow, what would you recommend be their first move?
Stan
I like to start out by surveying the organization to find out what its current views are on that. There can be a variety of questions that you ask. You’re trying to get a handle on what are the things that are viewed as both challenges and opportunities? What’s really bothering people because it’s hard for them to do? What do they see as an opportunity? If only we could have this, it would make life better. Getting a handle on that across as many people as you can in an organization gives you a sort of a baseline for this is what we would like to do. Then I like to talk to different levels of management, starting with the first-level managers, the middle managers up through executives, and find out how they view it and see if there’s any overlap between how they view these knowledge-related challenges and opportunities with what the grassroots answers were from the survey. And if I can find an intersection of those things and that fits also with my personal view of it, then that’s the ideal starting spot. So, you might get 10 different things from the masses, you might get 10 different things from management, and your own view might have 10 different things, but when you find the intersection point of those, maybe you’ll find one or two that are in all three of those areas. And then, if that’s true, that’s where you start. And you say, ‘Okay, the people really want this. Management also wants to see this done. And I personally think that’s a good idea. Let’s start there.’ Then start with one or two things, not with all of them, and try to do those really well. And then if those work really well, now you have the successes to draw on to try to do more.
You look for champions throughout your organization, people that share your views but may be in other roles, and you try to get those champions connected to each other, and you can form then sort of a virtual community or virtual team of people that believe in this, whether or not they’re actually knowledge management jobs, they’re people that want to at least spend part of their time helping you. And over time, that sort of network helps you build to the point where you may eventually be able to staff up.
The other thing you can do is look to see what’s already out there in terms of technology. Often in any large organization there’s already plenty of technology. There may be too many different things, and you’re trying to get a handle on that. So another survey can be used for that. You know, what tools are out there? What are you seeing? What would you like to see? And often you’ll hear back from people. This was my experience when I was at Compaq. It’s like we have too many tools. Can we get rid of some of them? Can we simplify? Simplification is easier than having to go out and acquire. You can just pick a few things that you think will work well and then get more people to start using them in a in a coordinated fashion. So there’s a lot of things you can do before you actually have to have a formal KM programme. But ultimately, if you’re going to do it well, you need at least one person whose job it is to do that, right? It doesn’t necessarily have to be a large organization. It’s hard to do it without at least one person who feels like it’s their mission.
Nancy
And once you have the passionate advocates surrounding you, that helps grease the machine for additional ideas and priorities to focus on. And you have the trust and confidence of those individuals who shared the early feedback on those friction points or those needs, who then can come back and support the system even further, in addition to giving you the outcomes that you can hang your hat on and show a measure of success to leadership. So, the combination of all of those things really supports the role and value of soliciting that feedback in the first and then creating that loop for ongoing success.
And so, just thinking ahead, where do you see knowledge management leaders or digital workplace leaders with a KM affinity going next? And is there one thing you’re hoping organizations will finally stop doing as part of that?
Stan
I always say that I want people to do the things that we already know work, right? So a lot of this is let’s just already take advantage of things we’ve learned over the last 30 years and do them well. So, as an example, if they’re not doing communities well, that’s an opportunity. And I always have this vision I talk about with communities: if we had one community for every important topic, but only one, no redundant communities; if everyone belonged to at least one community, including the one that was most relevant to their work; and if everyone paid attention to those communities and their discussions – if all those conditions apply, there’s a powerful promise that you can make, which is if anybody has any kind of a question or need or problem, they can go to a community that’s already in existence for that topic, pose their question or problem to the community, and be guaranteed to get back helpful replies in a reasonable time.
And that’s a powerful promise that you can’t really make with very many pieces of technology, right? You can’t say that about much, but in a community you can. So I’d say, start there. Let’s get communities right first. Let’s look at the other things that we’ve done over the last 30 years that have worked well and what we’ve learned and what we know, and let’s apply that. Let’s get that working right. And once we’ve started to apply the things we already know, then what’s next? What are the new frontiers? How can we use AI better than we’re using it today? What else is coming along? And be able to then add that incrementally. So, we should get incrementally better rather than kind of regressing back to we eliminated the KM programme, we have to start over, or we never got communities right, or you know, we don’t want to be reinventing the same mistakes that we’ve made over the last 30 years. We want to be building and getting better. So that’s where I would say we want to go. We want to do things that we already know work, do them well and more consistently across all organizations, and then see what’s next, how can we build from there.
Nancy
And just trying to tie this conversation together, is there one thing you were hoping I would ask and haven’t?
Stan
Well, let’s see. One thing I would say you haven’t asked me about what I would have done differently – let’s start with that.
Nancy
Mm-hmm.
Stan
I think that having been through it all, I think probably it would have been to be more aware of the short-term nature, the fact that my KM programme could at any moment be ended and with that in mind, maybe there would be different ways of figuring out alliances or ways to keep it and sustain it. So you wouldn’t be blindsided by a sudden ‘We’re eliminating your programme tomorrow’. If you expected that to happen, you might be more likely to plan for how to prevent it!
Nancy
That was a surprising outcome to that question. But I think it’s one of those things that can apply not just to the KM arena, but to a myriad of things that AI is disrupting at the moment. And, some time ago, I read an article about something called the ‘hotshot’ effect. And basically, the idea is that you think about the work that you’re charged with and think about if the company hired a hotshot to come into your role tomorrow, what would they do differently? And bring it back to yourself and say, if that’s the answer to what they would do, why wouldn’t I bring that into my work now instead of waiting for that hotshot to come? And that’s about peering beyond the blind corner that you were just describing and saying, ‘Take bold actions now to set yourself up for success after success.’
Stan
Yes, the term ‘bold action’ really speaks to me because I have people that I’m mentoring that talk about some of their frustrations in their organizations where they’re trying to take bold action or they have innovative ideas they’d love to see adopted, but they find resistance, right? And the question is why is there that resistance? And I think it gets back to people sort of being afraid to do anything that they think might jeopardize their job. And if that’s the environment you’re in, then it’s going to be tough to take those bold actions because people say ‘If I just stay out of visibility, maybe they won’t get rid of me’, which is of course the opposite of what you want. You want people to feel like they can take bold actions. They want innovations to be encouraged and tried, but in too many organizations that’s not the culture. And so, if you’re faced with that, I always advocate for ‘Be bold anyway’, right? And if it turns out that doesn’t work out and they don’t want bold people, then maybe you should go somewhere else where they do want it. But that shouldn’t hold you back from trying things. And that’s the way I’ve tried to be in my career. And I’ve had certainly opportunities where those bold actions have worked really well and have panned out. And, of course, at other times the programmes I’ve been leading have come to an end, right? But I wouldn’t probably change anything that I did in that regard. I think taking bold action is better than being tentative and timid.
Nancy
Yes. And those bold actions, if you’re following this conversation that we’re having, would be grounded in data and evidence because you’ve had the conversations with employees, you’ve had the conversations with leadership, so you’ve got the evidence you need to take things forward and affect the change that the organization needs.
Stan
I think that’s an important point because many times I’ll get into discussions online with people who are talking about knowledge management and they’ll make assertions that are based more on just things they’ve read rather than on experience they’ve had. And this comes up in a number of different ways. One example would be in the area of incentives. So, that’s one where there’s a wide variety of opinions, and many people will tell me that, you know, incentives don’t work and that you can only motivate people intrinsically, and if you try to use extrinsic motivation with leaderboards or rewards or anything like that, that won’t work. And my challenge to that was, ‘Well, I tried that. And what I found is that it did work.’ Maybe it wouldn’t work forever, but it certainly worked for a period of years. And so, the thing I believe there is that too many people rely on something that they’ve heard or they’ve read, but they haven’t tested themselves. And I always encourage people when you speak about bold action is don’t listen to what anyone else tells you. Take it into account, be aware of it. But if you believe that something actually might work, you’re better off trying that out and seeing for yourself if it works, rather than just saying, ‘No, we won’t do it because I read that it won’t work.’ And time after time in my career, when I tried something that I was told wouldn’t work, I found out that it did. To me that bolstered my belief, as you say, in evidence. Use evidence about things. That’s why I mentioned before, if we as a field will only do the things we already know have worked from evidence that we have assembled, we’ll be better off than if we don’t do those things. But time and again you’ll find people who say, ‘Well, that won’t work.’
Another example of this that’s come up was the area in communities there’s a rule that says only 10% of any community will ever post online and 90% will not. And some people view that as a bad thing. They use the term ‘lurkers’. People are ‘lurking’. And there’s two points I always make. Number one is you can’t do anything about it at all. There will always be 90% of people who won’t post. So don’t try to change that. It’s sort of a rule of nature. And number two is that’s okay – 90% of people, as long as they’re paying attention and learning from the community, that’s a good outcome, right? And what would happen if 100% of the community started posting? We’d be overwhelmed with material that we couldn’t keep up with! So it’s not a bad thing at all. But yet people will argue we’ve got to do something about that, we’ve got to get that 10% number up, we have to have greater engagement. And so my view is no, just make sure your community is large enough so that 10% of it is a meaningful number. So if you have a community that has 1000 members, that means 100 different people may post, and that’s pretty good. You don’t want 1000 people posting, because that’d be too much but 100 is good. But if you have a community with 10 people, then that’s not enough, because 10% of ten is one. And one person only posting is not good.
So, keep in mind, some of these things that people will argue with you, but then once again you can go back to evidence. So, when I was confronted with this point that the 90% rule is defunct, I go, ‘Wait a minute, based on what?’ Well, based on a survey that we did. Well, survey doesn’t really mean very much. Let’s look at some empirical data. So we actually did three different studies to look at actual data of communities. We found that actually it was closer to 5% was posting, not 10%. So, to say that somehow you’re going to get, you know, most of community posting: a) That’s not real; it’s not based on any real data; and number two, you don’t even want that!
Nancy
And the other thing that I think we have to factor in the mix is, just like learning styles, people consume information in different ways. And just because you haven’t verbalized something in the community doesn’t mean you haven’t taken specific action based on what you’ve been seeing and hearing. And so, you need to look at the total universe of change that’s been affected by both the active and seemingly passive individuals.
Stan
Right, and people will tell me regularly, ‘I like your stuff, I read your stuff, it’s great’ and they will never have done anything to indicate that otherwise. They won’t have replied or commented or liked or anything. But that’s okay because I realize they’re out there and they’re getting benefit out of it. And once in a while, when they tell me that, that’s just sort of proof of it. So the 90% of my community that will never post, I assume are still getting value from it, and that’s good. That’s the outcome I want.
Nancy
And so Stan, we’re coming up to the end of our time together. Final thought, final reflection, even a call to action?
Stan
The call to action would be to learn what’s already been done and that works and if you’re not doing it, do that. And then if you can say that we’re doing everything that’s ever been learned about KM and doing it successfully, then great, move on to something new and exciting. But don’t skip the step where you do the things that are tried and true before moving on to the new and exciting.
Nancy
Well, thank you for that final reflection. It’s been wonderful to have a chance to chat with you this afternoon and looking forward to continuing to follow your thoughts and insights and the conversations that you’re leading. But for now, I have to pause and say thank you and until next time.
Stan
Thanks Nancy.
Nancy
Digital Workplace Impact is brought to you by Digital Workplace Group. DWG is a strategic partner covering all aspects of the evolving digital workplace industry, not only through membership, but also boutique benchmarking and consulting services. For more information, visit digitalworkplacegroup.com.


“We have to put more emphasis on what we humans do well and how AI can assist us and not on what AI can replace us with. It can do a lot of things, but it can't replace human judgement. So, we need to be smart about what we replace – for instance, let's say you have an organization that has lots of people doing content cleansing.”
Knowledge Management Author, Speaker and Community Leader
Contact us to apply to join DWG as a member and become part of a community of more than 900 digital workplace and intranet leaders and practitioners.
Apply for membershipBook a free one-to-one consultation to review the current state of your digital workplace and discover how DWG expert guidance can help you move forward with confidence.